According to PYMNTS.com, Upwork President and CEO Hayden Brown characterized the labor market as “still sluggish” during the company’s Q3 earnings call on November 3, despite reporting significant growth in AI-related projects. The platform saw clients engaged in AI work increase 43% year-over-year, with gross services volume from AI projects growing 52% and professionals working on AI projects rising 41%. Meanwhile, Upwork’s total active client count declined 7% from 855,000 to 794,000 year-over-year, which CFO Erica Gessert attributed to focusing on “high-value relationships” rather than quantity. The most in-demand AI skills in September included Python, video editing, graphic design, ChatGPT, and AI-generated video, according to the company’s Monthly Hiring Report. This divergence between AI growth and overall market weakness reveals important market dynamics.
The AI Investment Priority Shift
What we’re witnessing is a classic case of strategic prioritization during economic uncertainty. Companies aren’t cutting all freelance spending—they’re redirecting it toward AI initiatives that promise immediate ROI and competitive advantage. The 52% GSV growth in AI projects suggests businesses view AI implementation as non-discretionary spending, even as they pull back on other freelance engagements. This creates a two-tier freelance market where AI specialists command premium rates while other categories face pricing pressure. The specific skills in demand—particularly Python and machine learning—indicate companies are building foundational AI capabilities rather than just experimenting with consumer-facing tools.
Platform Strategy in Transition
Upwork’s 7% decline in active clients alongside 7% growth in GSV per new client reveals a deliberate strategic pivot. By focusing on “high-value relationships,” Upwork is essentially trading volume for margin—a sensible approach in a softening market. This mirrors what we’ve seen in other platform businesses during economic downturns, where the most valuable customers become even more valuable while marginal users drop off. The risk here is that this strategy could make Upwork vulnerable to niche competitors targeting specific high-growth categories like AI, where specialized platforms might offer better talent matching and higher-quality outcomes.
Broader Market Implications
The bifurcation between AI growth and general market weakness has significant implications for the freelance economy. We’re likely to see increased specialization among freelancers, with those possessing AI skills commanding premium rates while generalists face increased competition. This could accelerate the professionalization of freelance work, creating clearer career paths for technical specialists. For platforms, the challenge will be balancing their high-value focus with maintaining sufficient liquidity in the marketplace. The 41% increase in professionals working on AI projects suggests freelancers are rapidly upskilling to meet demand, which could eventually ease the current supply constraints in this category.
Competitive Landscape Reshuffle
This AI-driven growth creates both opportunities and threats for Upwork against competitors like Fiverr and specialized AI talent platforms. While Upwork benefits from its scale and enterprise relationships, smaller platforms could potentially move faster to capitalize on specific AI skill categories. The demand for AI-generated video and ChatGPT expertise suggests we’re in the early innings of practical AI application, meaning the competitive dynamics could shift rapidly as new use cases emerge. Companies that can effectively match AI talent with business needs will capture disproportionate value, making this a critical battleground for all freelance platforms.
Your point of view caught my eye and was very interesting. Thanks. I have a question for you.